10.80 The Injustice of Restorative Justice
Restorative justice is an approach to justice in which a meeting is organized between the victim and the offender in which they discuss, sometimes in the presence of others, what the offender can do to repair the harm from the offense. This may include a payment of money given from the offender to the victim, apologies and other amends, and other actions to compensate the victim and to prevent the offender from causing future harm.
A restorative justice program aims to get offenders to take responsibility for their actions, to understand the harm they have caused, to give them an opportunity to redeem themselves, and to discourage them from causing further harm.
For victims, its goal is to give them an active role in the process and to reduce feelings of anxiety and powerlessness.
Sounds great until we learn what actually happens. One problem is who decides who is the victim and who is the offender. Another is who enforces that restitution takes place. Does anyone expect a bully to voluntarily give restitution to his or her victim?
Suzanne Gallagher, Director of Parent's Rights in Education, talks about Restorative Justice in the video below.
Restorative justice often punishes innocent children who were acting in self defense.
There are article and school administrations that claim that restorative justice is successful. Former teacher Tony Kinnett wrote:
While in the classroom and hallways it’s easy to see the behavior crisis, administrations proclaim the success of these progressive policies by citing lower numbers of suspensions, expulsions, and behavior referrals. What principals and counselors fail to mention is that the criteria for referrals have changed as a result of progressive policy. If a school refuses to expel a violent student, it does not have to record that negative action, therefore the number of expulsions continues to decline—while the violent student is sent back to class among the victims of his last fight. In fact, teachers are encouraged that a lack of behavioral standards is more "inclusive."
Tony wrote:
Edutopia reported in 2015 that Oakland California had implemented restorative justice practices, choosing small counseling sessions over traditional expectations and consequences, to great success. Just four years later, the Oakland Unified School police department reported responding to ~1,000 violent calls per semester.
Katherine Birbalsingh learned from experience that modern ideas of how to educate were bad and was outspoken about it and forced to resign. She in the face of a lot of opposition by progressives, founded the Michaela Community School in the inner city of London in 2014 to prove that traditional discipline, strict structure, and high academic expectations could lift disadvantaged inner-city children out of poverty. Academics and behavior at the school are at excellent levels—and classroom disruptions are extraordinarily rare. She and her teachers wrote a book proclaiming its success, praising the methods and resulting environment. You can see an interview with her below.
Restorative justice is applied not only in schools but also to violent criminals.
Christopher Rufo in his book America's Cultural Revolution wrote: In one high-profile case, prosecutors diverted a youth offender named Diego Carballo-Oliveros into a "peace circle" program, in which nonprofit leaders burned sage, passed around a talking feather, and led Carballo Oliveros through "months of self reflection." According to one corrections official with knowlege of the case, prosecutors and activists paraded Carballo-Oliveros around the city as the "shining example" of their approach. However, two weeks after completing the peace circle program, Carballo-Oliveros and two accomplices lured a fifteen year old boy into the woods robbed him and killed him.
Additional Links:
Teaching on the brink: How it feels to be an educator on the verge of quitting
https://www.frontpagemag.com/godmother-police-defunding-tried-restorative-daniel-greenfield/
https://www.frontpagemag.com/our-unsafe-schools/
![]() Lesson List |